I've ended up with an extra ticket to Aaron Tveit's concert at Webster Hall on 5/29, show starts at 8pm. This is an extra General Admission ticket.
Just looking to get back what we paid, which (including fees) was $44. Also willing to consider any reasonable offers at this point. I can accept Venmo payment, and can do a transfer via Ticketmaster, so you'll get the ticket right to your account. PM or comment if interested. Thanks!